Where the formulas came from
None of the four classic ideal weight formulas was written as a target for a person to reach. They were written so that a clinician could estimate a patient's lean mass from height alone, in a hurry, to dose a drug. The oldest, Hamwi's rule from 1964, came from diabetes practice: 48 kilograms for the first five feet of a man and 2.7 kilograms for every inch over, 45.5 and 2.2 for a woman. Devine's 1974 formula, 50 kilograms plus 2.3 per inch over five feet for men and 45.5 plus 2.3 for women, was published to calculate gentamicin doses and became the default in pharmacology because it was there.
Robinson and Miller, both in 1983, refitted Devine against actuarial tables. Robinson arrived at 52 plus 1.9 per inch for men and 49 plus 1.7 for women. Miller arrived at 56.2 plus 1.41 for men and 53.1 plus 1.36 for women. Each one is a straight line through height, and the lines have different slopes, so they cross and diverge.
Four answers for one person
A man of 5 feet 10 inches, ten inches over the five-foot base. Hamwi: 75.0 kilograms. Devine: 73.0. Robinson: 71.0. Miller: 70.3. A spread of 4.7 kilograms, or about ten pounds, from four formulas a doctor might cite with equal confidence.
A woman of 5 feet 5 inches. Miller: 59.9. Robinson: 57.5. Devine: 57.0. Hamwi: 56.5. Three and a half kilograms between the highest and the lowest. The ideal weight calculator shows all four together, each with its name and year, because showing one and calling it the ideal hides the disagreement that is the real finding.
The spread grows with height for men, because Hamwi's slope is nearly double Miller's, and the formulas are least reliable at the extremes of height where the original samples were thin.
The range that has evidence behind it
Body mass index, weight in kilograms over height in metres squared, is a crude measure and a well-studied one. The 18.5 to 24.9 band is associated in large population studies with the lowest rates of weight-related illness, which is a different kind of claim from a formula fitted to a 1960s insurance table. For the 5 foot 10 man that band runs from about 58.5 to 78.7 kilograms, and all four formulas sit comfortably inside it. For the 5 foot 5 woman it runs from about 50.4 to 67.9, and again all four fall within.
So the honest answer to how much should I weigh is a twenty-kilogram band, not a number, and the formulas are four points inside it. The BMI calculator gives the band for any height, and anywhere inside it is weight not being a health concern on its own.
What the formulas cannot see
Height is the only input, so the formulas and the BMI band both treat a sprinter and a sedentary office worker of the same height identically. Muscle is denser than fat, and a muscular person can sit above the band with a body fat percentage that is entirely healthy, while a person inside the band can carry more fat than is good for them. The frame-size adjustment some sites add, plus or minus ten percent for a large or small frame, is a guess layered on a guess.
What the weight is made of matters more than the total. The body fat calculator estimates composition from a few circumference measurements, and a result within the healthy range for body fat is a better signal than a formula weight hit to the kilogram. When the two disagree, composition wins.
Using the number, if you use it at all
Read the four formulas and the band together, notice where you sit, and treat the band as the answer. If change is wanted, the calorie calculator turns a target into a daily intake with a sensible rate, and a doctor or dietitian turns that into a plan that accounts for the things no formula sees. A formula written to dose antibiotics in 1974 was never meant to be the last word on anyone's body, and it is a relief to stop treating it as one.
Questions people ask
Because each was fitted to different data for a different purpose, mostly drug dosing, and each is a straight line through height with its own slope. Hamwi, Devine, Robinson and Miller differ by several kilograms at most heights; for a man of 5 feet 10 inches the spread is 70.3 to 75.0 kilograms.
None was designed to be a weight target, so accuracy is the wrong frame. Devine is the medical default because pharmacology adopted it. The BMI range of 18.5 to 24.9 has population evidence behind it, and all four formulas fall inside that band for most heights.
Hamwi says 75.0 kilograms, Devine 73.0, Robinson 71.0 and Miller 70.3. The healthy BMI band for that height runs from about 58.5 to 78.7 kilograms, and anywhere in it is weight not being a health concern on its own.
No. Height is the only input. A muscular person can sit above both the formulas and the BMI band with a healthy body fat percentage. Body composition, measured from circumferences or by a clinician, is the better signal when the two disagree.
Averaging four estimates that were never targets does not produce a target. Aim for anywhere inside the healthy BMI band, and let body composition and a clinician's advice decide where within it. The calculators show the band beside the formulas for that reason.

